Placing students at the heart of the iron triangle and the Interaction Equivalence Theorem Models
Published | December 2014 |
Type of work | Newcastle OER 2014 (Special Issue) |
Journal | Journal of Interactive Media in Education Volume 2014, Issue 2 |
Publisher | Ubiquity Press Ltd. |
ABSTRACT
A number of visual models have been proposed to help explain the interplay and interactions between specified components of higher education systems at different levels and to take account of emerging trends towards open education systems. At sector and institutional levels the notion of an iron triangle has been posited, linking firstly access, quality and cost and latterly accessibility, quality and efficiency in order to suggest means for widening access to higher education for the same or lower cost without compromising outcomes. At the level of teaching and learning an interaction equivalence theorem was developed to explain the relative contributions to successful study of teachers, students and educational content in formal settings and which has recently been extended to informal settings. However both models deal mainly with the supply side of the educational systems they attempt to represent, namely impacts of the availability and accessibility to more people of the elements in the models, and largely ignore the demand side in terms of the affordability and acceptability of the available and accessible provision to students and learners alike. Further, while stimulating debate there has to date been limited empirical studies undertaken to validate both these models. Despite this lack of testing, this paper explores ways of extending these existing models both visually and conceptually by adding in the perspective of the prospective learner or student in respect to their organisational capacity to invest sufficient time for studying, the levels of preparedness and/or confidence that they hold before they engage in learning and the level of motivation for undertaking those studies. It is argued that these modified models provide a new contextual framework with which to examine the capacity of more open education systems at the national, institutional and individual learner level to be expanded effectively and equitably. It is hoped that these extended models provide a new basis for undertaking empirical studies to test out the underlying assumptions.Keywords | diagrams · education systems · engagement · interaction equivalence theorem · iron triangle · Open Educational Resources |
ISSN | 1365-893X |
Refereed | Yes |
Rights | by/3.0 |
DOI | 10.5334/jime.ac |
URL | http://jime.open.ac.uk/article/view/jime.ac/544 |
Other information | JIME |
Export options | BibTex · EndNote · Tagged XML · Google Scholar |
AVAILABLE FILES
Viewed by 107 distinct readers
CLOUD COMMUNITY REVIEWS
The evaluations below represent the judgements of our readers and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Cloud editors.
Click a star to be the first to rate this document
▶ POST A COMMENT
SIMILAR RECORDS
Squaring the open circle: resolving the iron triangle and the interaction equivalence theorem
Lane, Andy
A number of visual models have been proposed to help explain the interplay and interactions between specified components of higher education systems at different levels and to take account of emerging trends towards ...
Match: Lane, Andy; diagrams; engagement; interaction equivalence theorem; iron triangle; Open Educational Resources
Re-invigorating openness at The Open University: The role of Open Educational Resources
Gourley, Brenda; Lane, Andy
This paper describes the internal motivations and external drivers that led The Open University UK to enter the field of Open Educational Resources through its institutionâwide OpenLearn initiative ...
Match: Lane, Andy; Open Educational Resources
Reuse and repurpose: the life story of an (open) educational resource
Lane, Andy
This paper relates the life story of a particular educational resource (and its lead author) that went from being closed to open and which exemplifies the value of reuse and reworking of educational resources in both ...
Match: Lane, Andy; Open Educational Resources
Developing innovative systems for supportive open teaching practices in higher education
Lane, Andy
Openness has become a key feature in the discourse and practice of higher education in recent years as has its potential to drive innovation in teaching and learning practices. More often this discourse refers to the ...
Match: Lane, Andy; Open Educational Resources
Production of OER, a quest for efficiency
Schuwer, Robert; Wilson, Tina; van Valkenburg, Willem; Lane, Andy
In most initiatives to publish Open Educational Resources (OER), the production of OER is the activity with the highest costs. Based on literature and personal experiences a list of relevant characteristics of ...
Match: Lane, Andy; Open Educational Resources
A review of the role of national policy and institutional mission in European distance teaching universities with respect to widening participation in higher education study through open educational resources
Lane, Andy
The open educational resources (OER) movement is relatively new with few higher education institutions (HEIs) publishing or using them, and even fewer using them to widen engagement or participation in HE study. ...
Match: Lane, Andy; Open Educational Resources
Out of Africa: A typology for analysing open educational resources initiatives
Bateman, Peter; Lane, Andy; Moon, Bob
This paper describes how a typology was developed and used between 2008 and 2010 to investigate three different open educational resources (OER) initiatives in Sub Saharan Africa (SSA). The typology was first developed ...
Match: Lane, Andy; Open Educational Resources
An emerging typology for analysing OER initiatives
Bateman, Peter; Lane, Andy; Moon, Robert
The investigation of OER initiatives requires rigorous appraisal based on theory as well as descriptions based on practice if we are to understand them and how they might be sustained. A robust typology or flexible ...
Match: Lane, Andy; Open Educational Resources
OpenLearn research report 2006-2008
McAndrew, Patrick; Santos, A.; Lane, Andy; Godwin, Stephen; et al.
This report takes the experience of OpenLearn over its two-years of operation to reflect on what it means to offer free resources and the issues that we have been able to explore and learn from. The structure of the ...
Match: Lane, Andy; Open Educational Resources
Diffusion and adoption of Open Educational Resources
Lane, Andy; van Dorp, Cornelis Adrianus
This paper reviews and reflects on institutional OER development practices along the dimensions and models of collaboration and innovation within communities and networks of practice, and provides insights as how to ...
Match: Lane, Andy; Open Educational Resources