Thoughts on Plan S
Suber, Peter

PublishedSeptember 2018
Type of workBlog
RegionEurope

ABSTRACT
Overview. The plan is admirably strong. It aims to cover all European research, in the sciences and in the humanities, at the EU level and the member-state level. It's a plan for a mandate, not just an exhortation or encouragement. It keeps copyright in the hands of authors. It requires open licenses and prefers CC-BY. It abolishes or phases out embargoes. It does not support hybrid journals except as stepping stones to full-OA journals. It's willing to pay APCs but wants to cap them, and wants funders and universities to pay them, not authors. It will monitor compliance and sanction non-compliance. It's already backed by a dozen powerful, national funding agencies and calls for other funders and other stakeholders to join the coalition.

There are two main weaknesses or aspects to watch closely. First, on one reading, the plan welcomes both gold and green OA, which is good. Its key principle requires distribution through "compliant Open Access Journals...or compliant Open Access Platforms." But a section elucidating this principle damns green OA with faint praise, endorsing OA repositories only for preservation, not for OA itself, repeating the mistake of the Finch Group in 2012. It's not at all clear how far the coalition will let green OA satisfy the upcoming policies.

Second, the plan promises support for OA infrastructure, which is good. But it never commits to open infrastructure, that is, platforms running on open-source software, under open standards, with open APIs for interoperability, preferably owned or hosted by non-profit organizations. This omission invites the fate that befell bepress and SSRN, but this time for all European research.

Keywords cOAlition S · gold and green OA · OA policy · open licenses · Plan S

RefereedDoes not apply
URLhttps://plus.google.com/+PeterSuber/posts/iGEFpdYY9dr
Access date2018
Export optionsBibTex · EndNote · Tagged XML · Google Scholar


Viewed by 190 distinct readers




CLOUD COMMUNITY REVIEWS

The evaluations below represent the judgements of our readers and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Cloud editors.

Click a star to be the first to rate this document


POST A COMMENT
SIMILAR RECORDS

New coalition of European funders join together to place unprecedented mandate on researchers to publish OA
SPARC
This week, a promising new initiative aimed at greatly accelerating the migration to a fully Open Access research environment in Europe was announced: Plan S. Backed by 11 national funding organisations joined together ...
Match: coalition s; oa policy; plan s; europe

Plan de acción Conocimiento Abierto: marco de actuación
Universitat Oberta de Catalunya; Gmelch, Nadja; Xarles, Gemma; Martínez Samper, Pastora
Nos encontramos ante unos retos globales de nuevas dimensiones, la mayo-ría relacionados entre sí y recogidos en gran parte en la Agenda 2030 para el Desarrollo Sostenible de las Naciones Unidas. La Agenda 2030 define ...
Match: plan; europe

Obama highlights open education in U.S. Open Government Partnership National Action Plan
Creative Commons
Yesterday at the United Nations, President Barack Obama marked the Open Government Partnership‘s (OGP) third anniversary by announcing that in addition to the commitments outlined in the current U.S. OGP National ...
Match: plan

Q & A Key Answers about the OER University Plan
Mackintosh, Wayne; Open Education Resource Foundation
Five Open Educational Resource University (OERu) questions answered: 1) Why is OERu significant? 2) How does OERu work? 3) What are the recurrent operational costs? 4) What are the benefits? 5) How to become an anchor ...
Match: plan

Open Educational Resources: A regional university’s journey
Koroivulaono, Theresa
In a region of geographically scattered, small island states, developing quality-enhanced learning materials across the hugely diverse, predominantly ocean-based learning and teaching environments, continues to present ...

Eager adopters in education: Strategic plan ideas for integrating instructional technology
Hargis, Jace
Strategic plans for teaching and learning are essential, however, they tend to focus on moving a mass of stakeholders along an agreeable path. The strategy is necessary and sensible, although many times, these plans ...
Match: plan; europe

Thoughts on Open Access: An Interview with Diane Graves
Dazey, Megan; Parks, Bonnie
Megan Dazey speaks with Diane Graves, University Librarian, about her work with open access and scholarly communication at Trinity University. Graves discusses Trinity University's recent adoption of an open access ...
Match: thoughts

eCampusOntario strategic plan 2016-2018
eCampusOntario
Online and technology-enabled learning continues to evolve and grow providing increasing access and opportunities for learners to pursue education in fl exible ways to meet their needs. In 2013, the Ministry of Advanced ...
Match: plan

An action plan for building a statewide infrastructure to support OER in Florida's public institutions of higher education
Dygert, Claire; The OATER Task Force
This report provides recommendations to the Florida Virtual Campus from the Open Access Textbook and Educational Resources (OATER) Task Force on how to build an infrastructure to support OER efforts on a statewide basis ...
Match: plan

Canada’s draft action plan on open government 2.0
Government of Canada
Canada's Action Plan on Open Government 2014-2016 Draft for consultation Table of Contents Introduction Achievements to Date Developing Canada's Action Plan 2.0 Canada's Action Plan 2.0 Commitments Open Government ...
Match: plan