Implications of the Delphi method in the evaluation of sustainability open education resource repositories
Wang, Xiaochen · Chen, Tingting · Zhang, Yihan · Yang, Harrison Hao

Published4 February 2021
JournalEducation and Information Technologies
Volume 2021
PublisherSpringer Nature
CountryChina, Asia

ABSTRACT
To better understand the sustainable development of open educational resources (OER), this paper aimed to break through the original ‘fixed’, highly structured evaluation system and develop an open and flexible “1 + X” evaluation framework of OER by using the modified Delphi method. “1” refers to the mandatory basic criteria that the repository must reflect essential attributes and core functions, which are consist of four components: information content, learning process, system technology, and user experience. “X” refers to optional distinctive criteria that the repository shall focus on one or more developmental orientations, which may include: resource evolution, international collaboration, inclusiveness and equality, open educational practices, and value-added services. Optional “X” criteria, in line with the criteria’s diversity aims, can lead to the sustainable development of OER and globalized lifelong learning. The framework of this study provides a basis for the evaluation and optimization of existing OER repositories, and also serves as functional scaffolding for the construction of new repositories.

Keywords open educational resources · repository · evaluation criteria · Delphi method · sustainable development

Published atBeijing
LanguageEnglish
RefereedYes
RightsSpringer Nature
DOI10.1007/s10639-021-10452-z
Export optionsBibTex · EndNote · Tagged XML · Google Scholar


Viewed by 144 distinct readers




CLOUD COMMUNITY REVIEWS

The evaluations below represent the judgements of our readers and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Cloud editors.

Click a star to be the first to rate this document


POST A COMMENT
SIMILAR RECORDS

The evolution of sustainability models for Open Educational Resources: insights from the literature and experts
Tlili, Ahmed; Nascimbeni, Fabio; Burgos, Daniel; Zhang, Xiangling; et al.
The adoption of Open Educational Resources (OER) can, on the one hand, increase access and quality in higher education, but on the other hand it is raising concerns among universities and researchers about its economic ...
Match: sustainability; china

Open Educational Resources: New possibilities for change and sustainability
Friesen, Norm
In an attempt to understand the potential of OER for change and sustainability, this paper presents the results of an informal survey of active and inactive collections of online educational resources, emphasizing data ...
Match: sustainability

OER on the Asian mega universities: 
Developments, motives, openness, and sustainability
Farisi, Mohammad Imam
The OER movement originated and integrated into ODE developments. Mega Universities (MUs) are among the most important of ODE providers worldwide should be to be the primary organizations for providing access to OER. So ...
Match: sustainability; asia

Examining the sustainability issues in UKOER projects: Developing a sustainable OER ecosystem in HE
Yuan, Li; Robertson, John R.; Campbell, Lorna M.; Pegler, Chris
The development of open educational resources (OERs) is becoming a strategic priority for governments and education institutions around the world, in response to funding cuts and rising costs in educational provision. ...
Match: sustainability

Advancing sustainability of Open Educational Resources
Koohang, Alex; Harman, Keith
This paper discusses the concept of Open Educational Resources (OERs). The discussion then shift to OER sustainability, a fundamental element essential for the success of OER. Special attention is given to the following ...
Match: sustainability

A preliminary exploration of the relationships between student-created OER, sustainability, and students success
Wiley, David; Webb, Ashley; Weston, Sarah; Tonks, DeLaina
This article explores the relationship between open educational resources (OER) created by students for use by other students, the long-term sustainability of the movement toward OER, and the success of students who use ...
Match: sustainability

Determinants of open educational resources adoption and their impact on educational sustainability: A cross-cultural comparison using SEM-fsQCA
Alkawsi, Gamal; Al-Sharafi, Mohammed A.; AlAjmi, Qasim
This cross-cultural study investigates the factors influencing the adoption of open educational resources (OER) and their impact on educational sustainability in Malaysia and Oman. The research extends the Unified ...
Match: sustainability; asia

Open-access textbooks and financial sustainability: A case study on flat world knowledge
Hilton, John Levi; Wiley, David A.
Many college students and their families are concerned about the high costs of textbooks. A company called Flat World Knowledge both gives away and sells open-source textbooks in a way it believes to be financially ...
Match: sustainability

User-generated content’s impact on the sustainability of Open Educational Resources
Ganapathi, Janani
Sustainability is a fundamental requirement to ensure long-term viability of open educational resource (OER) initiatives. To afford technology upgrades and author costs, most of the existing initiatives are heavily ...
Match: sustainability

Building a manifesto for OER sustainability: UK experiences
Pegler, Chris
Evidence of sustainability, or the potential to achieve this, is increasingly a pre-requisite for OER activity, whether imposed by funders, by institutions requiring a 'business case' for OER, or practitioners ...
Match: sustainability