Efficacy of open textbook adoption on learning performance and course withdrawal rates: A meta-analysis
Published | 2019 |
Journal | AERA Open Volume 5, Issue 3, Pages 1-20 |
Country | United States, North America |
ABSTRACT
Open textbooks have been developed in response to rising commercial textbook costs and copyright constraints. Numerous stud-ies have been conducted to examine open textbooks with varied findings. The purpose of this study is to meta-analyze the findings of studies of postsecondary students comparing learning performance and course withdrawal rates between open and commer-cial textbooks. Based on a systematic search of research findings, there were no differences in learning efficacy between open textbooks and commercial textbooks (k = 22, g = 0.01, p = .87, N = 100,012). However, the withdrawal rate for postsecondary courses with open textbooks was significantly lower than that for commercial textbooks (k = 11, OR (odds ratio) = 0.71, p = .005, N = 78,593). No significant moderators were identified. Limitations and future directions for research, such as a need for more work in K–12 education, outside of North America, and that better examine student characteristics, are discussed.Keywords | open textbooks · course withdrawal · open educational resources · meta-analysis |
Language | English |
Refereed | Yes |
Rights | CC BY-NC |
DOI | 10.1177/2332858419872212 |
Export options | BibTex · EndNote · Tagged XML · Google Scholar |
AVAILABLE FILES
Viewed by 199 distinct readers
CLOUD COMMUNITY REVIEWS
The evaluations below represent the judgements of our readers and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Cloud editors.










Click a star to be the first to rate this document
▶ POST A COMMENT
SIMILAR RECORDS
Adapting and adopting Open Educational Resources: An analysis of student cost savings, use, performance, and perception
Springer, Mike T.
OER’s are significant in terms of cost-savings to the student, but there are questions surrounding the quality of these resources, as well as whether students prefer OER or traditional textbooks. Many of the OER’s ...
Match: performance; united states; north america
The Impact of OER’s Continuous Improvement Cycles on Students’ Performance: A Longitudinal Analysis of the RISE Framework
Castellanos-Reyes, Daniela; Camargo Salamanca, Sandra Liliana; Wiley, David
Open educational resources (OER) have been praised for revolutionizing education. However, practitioners and instructors battle keeping OER updated and measuring their impact on students’ performance. Few studies have ...
Match: performance; united states; north america
MOOC-based flipped learning in higher education: students’ participation, experience and learning performance
Wang, Kai; Zhu, Chang
Relying on advanced network technologies, Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs) can support the transformation and deep construction of high-quality open courses. However, with the use of MOOCs in many universities and ...
Match: performance
Effectiveness of OER use in first-year higher education students' mathematical course performance: A case study
Westermann Juárez, Werner; Venegas Muggli, Juan Ignacio; Hodgkinson-Williams, Cheryl; Arinto, Patricia B.
This chapter aims to understand the impact of Open Educational Resources (OER) on first-year mathematics students at the Instituto Profesional Providencia (IPP) in Santiago, Chile, where more than half (52%) of ...
Match: performance
Identifying the Factors Affecting Student Academic Performance and Engagement Prediction in MOOC using Deep Learning: A Systematic Literature Review
Rizwan, Shahzad; Nee, Chee Ken; Garfan, Salem
The increasing reliance on Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs) has transformed the landscape of education, particularly during the COVID-19 pandemic, where e-learning became essential. However, the effectiveness of ...
Match: performance
Integrating an open textbook into undergraduate teacher education
Cavanaugh, Terence
As K12 schools move to open textbooks it becomes important that teacher preparation programs also begin to integrate this text format. This paper presented how an introductory educational technology undergraduate course ...
Match: open textbooks; united states; north america
Open Textbooks at St. Cloud University: A Collective Case Study
Lundeen-Hoff, Sally
This starred paper offers a review of existing literature about open educational resources (OER), describes the methodology selected to research OER use at St. Cloud State University, outlines the results of a ...
Match: open textbooks; united states; north america
Crossing the chasm: A case of scaling adoption of Open Educational Resources to the early majority
Correa, Alma; Perman, Amertah E.; Rivaldi, Matthew; Bulger, Stephanie R.; et al.
Due to the ongoing trend of increased higher education costs, state and federal strategies have been implemented in an effort to lower students' cost of college. One such strategy gaining nationwide attention is the ...
Match: open textbooks; united states; north america
Open 101: An action plan for affordable textbooks
Vitez, Kaitlyn; The Student PIRGS
Skyrocketing textbook prices for common university courses are adding insult to the burdensome debt students assume to pay for college. This new report investigates those high textbook prices for common courses at ...
Match: open textbooks; united states; north america
Using Open Educational Resources at Viterbo University: Faculty and Student Feedback
Oelfke, Alissa L.; Sadowski, Jennifer A.; Mathwig Ramseier, Cari; Iremonger, Christopher; et al.
This study evaluated a coordinated and collaborative pilot implementation of open educational resources (OER) across multiple disciplines including nursing, accounting, environmental science, religious studies, and ...
Match: open textbooks; united states; north america