OER as online edutainment resources: A critical look at open content, branded content, and how both affect the OER movement
Moe, Rolin

PublishedJuly 2015
JournalLearning, Media and Technology
Volume 40, Issue 3, Pages 350 - 364

ABSTRACT
Despite a rise in awareness and production of open education resources (OER) over the past decade, mainstream media outlets continue to define open in economic terms of consumer cost and not in theoretical terms of remix or appropriation. This period in the open access debate has coincided with a proliferation of free-of-charge video content available on the internet, branded with institutional affiliation and labeled as educational or edutainment resources. Videos from organizations such as TED, Curiosity.com and Upworthy have gained scholastic use and are being labeled as OER, despite a missive from their organizations to limit consumer use of the videos to viewing and sharing. Viewed instrumentally, the lack of remix utility for this edutainment creates only a slight distinction between their product and OER-as-defined. However, when viewed from a critical theory lens, the content-as-brand video edutainment phenomenon is strikingly different from the OER movement, and the lack of mainstream clarity on the delineation has created confusion in the OER movement, potentially a serious problem for the future of the OER movement as a social value rather than only a free tool. This paper utilizes a critical theory framework to identify the sociocultural, economic and political differences between traditional OER and institutionally derived video content. Building upon Jean-Francois Lyotard's criticism of grand narratives in the schema of knowledge, the paper begins with an historical literature review of edutainment in the guise of OER, and how the development and consumption of branded content strengthens a sociopolitical rendering of knowledge as a commodity rather than a ubiquitous public good. The paper then compares contemporary media coverage and cultural cache of OER content with that of branded edutainment content. Efforts to consolidate OER practitioners around a critical definition of OER, as well as opportunities to differentiate between OER and free-of-charge edutainment in the mainstream media, are important issues for further study.

Keywords commodification · critical theory · edutainment · knowledge · Lyotard · OER · online education

ISSN1743-9892
RefereedYes
RightsCopyright © 2016 Informa UK Limited
DOI10.1080/17439884.2015.1029942
Other informationLearning, Media and Technology
Export optionsBibTex · EndNote · Tagged XML · Google Scholar


Viewed by 134 distinct readers




CLOUD COMMUNITY REVIEWS

The evaluations below represent the judgements of our readers and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Cloud editors.

Click a star to be the first to rate this document


POST A COMMENT
SIMILAR RECORDS

Two models for sharing digital open educational resources
Rennie, Frank; Reynolds, Patricia
Two contrasting models to facilitate the sharing of digital educational resources available for Higher Education are reviewed. The first model is based upon a low-input / open-access format that identifies, reviews then ...
Match: resources; oer; online education

Alternate academy: Investigating the use of Open Educational Resources by students at the University of Lagos in Nigeria
Onaifo, Daniel; Quan-Haase, Anabel
Open educational resources (OER) are increasingly used to support pedagogical initiatives and learning needs at institutions of higher education across the globe. In this thesis, I examined key issues in the use of OER ...
Match: resources; oer

National Repository of Open Education for all Educational Resources: Connecting knowledge connecting people
Anubhuti, Yadav
Abstract The National Repository of Open Educational Resources (NROER) is an Indian school education initiative by the Central Institute of Educational technology ( CIET), National Council for Educational Research & ...
Match: resources

Open educational resources - An opportunity and a challenge for students
Birzina, Rita
The use of Open Educational Resources (OERs) in higher education is becoming increasingly urgent. Therefore it is essential to find out students' views on the opportunities and challenges gained by applying OERs. In the ...
Match: resources; oer

Impact of Open Educational Resources on course DFWI rates in undergraduate online education
Shaw, Cassandra S.; Irwin, Kathleen C.; Blanton, Doris
The purpose of this study was to determine the relationship between the use of Open Educational Resources (OER) and course DFWI (Drop, Fail, Withdrawal, Incomplete) rates at the undergraduate level of an online ...
Match: resources; oer; online education

Open Educational Resources (Including MOOCs)
Pulist, S. K.; Leal Filho, W.; Azul, A. M.; Brandli, L.; et al.
The introduction of Open Educational Resources (OER) in the form of open courseware took place with the announcement of MIT in 2001 to put substantial number of courses on their website to be available to all for free. ...
Match: resources; oer

Business models for online education and open educational resources
Okoli, Chitu; Wang, Ning
This project aims to determine the key stakeholders, goals and existing business models for online education and open educational resources (OER) by focusing on three major research questions: • Who are the key ...
Match: resources; oer; online education

Differentiation in access to, and the use and sharing of (Open) Educational Resources among students and lecturers at Kenyan Universities
Pete, Judith; Mulder, Fred; Neto, Jose Oliveira
In order to obtain a fair ‘OER picture’ for the Global South a large-scale study has been carried out for a series of countries, including Kenya. In this paper we report on the Kenya study, run at four universities ...
Match: resources; oer

Open Educational Resources: Higher education students' knowledge and use
Alves, Paulo; Miranda, Luísa; Morais, Carlos
Information and communication technologies represent one of the main innovation factors within the teaching and learning process, especially in Higher Education. In this context, the search for building useful and ...
Match: resources

Public expenditure in education in Latin America. Recommendations to serve the purposes of the Paris Open Educational Resources Declaration
Hernández, Amalia Toledo; Botero, Carolina; Guzmán, Luisa
In this paper, the authors identify and analyze public policy and the investment and expenditure that the governments of Argentina, Chile, Colombia, Paraguay and Uruguay commit to make in the development and procurement ...
Match: resources; oer